Accounting Principles for Software Development
Technology companies navigate complex financial landscapes, particularly when accounting for software development costs. Adhering strictly to GAAP ensures accuracy and consistency.
GAAP Overview
Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) provide a framework that dictates how technology companies should record and manage their financial transactions. Within these principles are specific guidelines for recognizing and handling costs associated with software development.
Matching Principle
The matching principle is a fundamental concept in accounting that requires companies to report an expense on the income statement in the period in which the related revenues are earned. This principle underpins the decision-making process for capitalizing or expensing software development costs.
Capitalization vs. Expensing
Determining whether to capitalize or expense software development costs is a critical decision for technology companies. Costs are capitalized if they will benefit the company over multiple periods; otherwise, they are expensed as incurred. Capitalizing software means recognizing it as an asset, whereas expensing means treating the costs as an immediate hit to the company’s income statement.
Software Development Costs Under U.S. GAAP
Under U.S. GAAP, the treatment of software development costs depends on the nature and stage of the project. There are specific capitalization rules:
- Preliminary Project Stage: Costs should be expensed as incurred.
- Application Development Stage: Costs can be capitalized if they add value, extend the software’s life, or enable new functionalities.
- Post-Implementation/Operation Stage: Ongoing costs must typically be expensed, unless they relate to upgrades and enhancements contributing additional value.
Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 350-40: Internal-Use Software and ASC 985-20: Costs of Software to Be Sold, Leased, or Marketed provide the specific guidelines on which costs are to be capitalized and the conditions under which this can occur.
Understanding Software Development Costs
Technology companies carefully navigate the accounting of software development costs by discerning the nature of these expenses and the appropriate accounting treatment—capitalization versus expensing. These decisions hinge on a clear understanding of the stages of software development and the associated costs.
Identifying Software Development Costs
Identifying software development costs is the first step in determining their accounting treatment. These costs encompass a range of expenses including planning, manpower (coding and testing activities), and associated overheads. Clear identification helps in segregating costs that may be capitalized from those that should be expensed immediately.
Technological Feasibility Phase
The Technological Feasibility Phase is critical in the capitalization process. It begins after the preliminary project stage and is the point when a company determines whether the project is technically and financially feasible. For a project following the waterfall development model, this would typically take place after thorough documentation and before the actual application development begins. In contrast, under the agile development model, feasibility may be determined after certain iterations or sprints.
Preliminary Project Stage
During the Preliminary Project Stage, activities include conceptual formulation and evaluation of alternatives, and costs are usually expensed as incurred. This stage entails initial planning and designing efforts before the establishment of technological feasibility, which are not capitalizable as per GAAP.
Application Development Stage
Once technological feasibility is established, the Application Development Stage commences. Capitalizable costs at this stage might include expenses related to software design, coding, and testing activities. The approach—whether waterfall or agile (sprints)—guides the timing of cost capitalization.
Post-Implementation and Maintenance Phase
Costs incurred during the Post-Implementation and Maintenance Phase are generally expensed as they are aimed at maintaining existing software rather than enhancing its value. These activities involve routine, ongoing efforts to correct errors or keep the software operational after it’s been implemented and put into use.
Capitalizing Software Development Costs
Technology companies often face the challenge of differentiating between costs that should be capitalized versus those that should be expensed when it comes to software development. The capitalization of software development costs is a critical aspect of accounting within the software industry, governed by specific criteria and accounting standards.
Criteria for Capitalization
In order for software development costs to be capitalized, specific criteria must be met. Under GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles), the costs incurred during particular stages of software development can be capitalized if:
- The software is intended to be sold, leased, or otherwise marketed to external users.
- The software is intended for internal use and the company can demonstrate its intention and ability to complete the development successfully.
Internal-Use Software Capitalization
For software that is developed for internal use, the capitalization of costs begins once the preliminary project stage is complete and the application development stage has commenced. Under ASC 350-40, the costs that can be capitalized include:
- Direct costs associated with software development such as coding, testing, and software implementation.
- Payroll and payroll-related expenses for employees who are directly associated with the software development project.
Software to Be Sold, Leased, or Marketed
For software products intended for commercial sale, lease, or market, capitalization of software development costs begins after establishing technological feasibility. According to ASC 985-20, costs must be significant and incurred during the application and development stage such as coding and testing activities.
ASC 350 and ASC 985 Guidelines
The software industry follows specific guidelines from:
- ASC Topic 350, which relates to internal-use software and details the capitalization of associated development costs.
- ASC 985-20, focused on software development costs for products to be sold, addressing how and when development costs should be capitalized.
Companies adhere to these standards to ensure accurate financial reporting and compliance with accounting principles, impacting the timing and amount of expense recognition.
Impact on Financial Statements
Technology companies confront critical accounting decisions when it comes to software development costs, specifically regarding capitalization vs. expensing. These decisions directly affect their financial statements, reflecting in variances in net income, asset valuation, and disclosure in financial reports such as the 10-K.
Effects on Balance Sheet
When a technology company capitalizes software development costs, these costs are classified as intangible assets on the balance sheet. During the development phase, capitalized costs increase total assets, subsequently affecting shareholder equity. The useful life of the software determines the period over which these capitalized costs will be amortized. Once amortization commences, it reduces the book value of intangible assets and is distributed across the useful life of the software.
Influences on Income Statement
Amortization of intangible assets appears on the income statement as a non-cash expense. Initially, capitalizing software development costs leads to higher net income since expenses are not immediately recognized. In contrast, expensed costs are deducted from revenue in the period they occur, which can result in lower net income during the development stage. Over time, amortized costs gradually impact the income statement, reflecting the consumption of the asset’s economic benefits.
Disclosure in Financial Reports
Disclosures in financial reports like the 10-K provide transparency regarding accounting for software development costs. Companies are required to disclose their accounting policies for capitalization and amortization, including the criteria for when a software project can be capitalized and how useful life is determined. These disclosures offer insight into future implications of the capitalization of development costs and the prospective expense recognition affecting net income.
Specific Cost Considerations
In accounting for software development costs, technology companies weigh various expenses associated with the creation and implementation of a computer software product. Each category of cost requires careful evaluation to determine if it should be capitalized or expensed.
Internal and External Development Expenses
For internal-use software, costs incurred during the preliminary project stage are typically expensed. However, costs during the application development stage, such as programming and program design, might be capitalized. For software to be sold, leased, or marketed to customers, the development costs are often capitalized once technological feasibility is established.
Costs of Upgrades and Enhancements
Costs related to upgrades and enhancements that provide additional functionality may be capitalized, subject to meeting specific criteria for capitalization. In contrast, maintenance costs for existing functionality are generally expensed as they’re incurred.
Data Conversion and Training Costs
Data conversion costs, excluding the costs to develop or obtain software that enables data conversion, are usually expensed. Conversely, training costs are expensed as they do not typically add value to the software product itself.
Overhead and Interest Costs
When considering overhead costs, only those that are directly associated with developing the software may be capitalized. Interest costs incurred during the development can be capitalized but only if they meet the conditions outlined in specific accounting standards.
Industry Practices and Examples
In the technology sector, accounting for software development costs is pivotal, defining the financial health and valuation of companies. Practices vary by entity type and reflect diverse strategies, from SaaS to cloud services.
Public Company Disclosures
Public companies in the technology industry, such as Google, are required to disclose their accounting policies, including those around software development costs. These disclosures provide insight into whether costs are capitalized or expensed. For example, when Google develops a new software platform or updates its existing offerings, the associated research and development costs must be presented in its financial statements. Any costs that Google capitalizes are commonly classified as intangible assets under fixed assets on the balance sheet.
Common Software Development Accounting Policies
Technology companies typically follow U.S. GAAP or IFRS, which involve specific criteria to determine the capitalization or expensing of software development costs. For software being sold or marketed, costs incurred during the application development stage are often capitalized. Hosting arrangements also affect the capitalization of software: if a customer can take possession of the software, the related costs might be capitalized. Here are the typical policies in a list format:
- Pre-development Costs: Often expensed as incurred.
- Development Costs: May be capitalized when technological feasibility is established.
- Post-implementation Costs: Usually expensed unless they add additional functionality.
CEOs, CFOs, and Controllers Perspective
The leaders of technology companies — CEOs, CFOs, and Controllers — play a vital role in setting and overseeing these accounting policies. Their perspective considers regulatory compliance, business strategy, and operational efficiencies. For SaaS companies, determining the capitalization of development costs is not just an accounting issue but also an aspect of strategic positioning that impacts how the business scales and controls its payroll costs and material expenses. These executives must balance the immediate financial impact of expensing versus the long-term benefits of capitalization, particularly as it relates to investment in cloud infrastructure and platforms.
Recent Developments and Trends
The landscape of accounting for software development costs has seen considerable changes with the evolution of software development methodologies and cloud technologies.
Evolution of Agile and Waterfall Models
In recent years, agile development has continued to dominate as a preferred method of software development, emphasizing incremental progress, flexibility, and customer collaboration. The accounting treatment of these costs often aligns with the iterative nature of the agile approach, where expenditures can be expensed or capitalized based on the stage of development. On the other hand, waterfall development, a more traditional and linear approach, generally sees costs capitalized during the development phase after the establishment of technological feasibility and expensed as the product is developed.
Impact of Cloud Computing and SaaS
The shift towards cloud computing and Software as a Service (SaaS) models has also influenced how technology companies capitalize software development costs. With cloud-based services, companies are more likely to expense the costs as they are incurred due to the ongoing nature of SaaS updates and maintenance. This contrasts with capitalized costs more common in traditional software development, where there is a clearly defined project with a start and end date leading to the creation of a distinct software product.
The recognition of development costs significantly hinges on whether the software is for internal use, sold to customers, or part of a SaaS offering. Costs in a cloud environment are often operational and therefore expensed as they enable continuous delivery of services rather than leading up to a singular saleable software product.
Frequently Asked Questions
When addressing the accounting of software development costs, technology companies face complex decisions about whether to capitalize or expense these costs. The following frequently asked questions provide clarity on international financial reporting standards, GAAP regulations, and common accounting practices within the industry.
What criteria must be met for software development costs to be capitalized according to IFRS?
Under IFRS, companies may capitalize software development costs when it is probable that the software will generate future economic benefits and the costs can be measured reliably. These costs are included in the development phase, post the initial research phase.
How do GAAP regulations affect the capitalization of software acquired for external use?
For software intended for external use, GAAP allows capitalization once the preliminary project stage is complete, and it is probable that the project will be completed and used as intended. Costs during the application development stage can be capitalized, whereas costs for the preliminary stage must be expensed.
What are the typical accounting practices for capitalizing versus expensing purchased software licenses?
Purchased software licenses, if they provide future economic benefits beyond a single reporting period, are typically capitalized as a fixed asset. If such licenses have only a short-term benefit or are part of a subscription, they are usually expensed in the period incurred.
What constitutes the point at which software development costs can start being capitalized?
Software development costs can be capitalized when an entity has demonstrated the software’s technical feasibility, and it has committed the necessary resources to complete the software so that it will be available for use or sale.
How do companies differentiate between capitalization and expensing of research and development costs?
Companies differentiate between these costs by considering the stage of the development. Research costs are usually expensed as they are incurred since future economic benefits are less certain. Development costs can be capitalized once technological feasibility is established.
Can you provide an example of a journal entry for capitalized software development costs?
When software development costs meet capitalization criteria, the costs are debited to a Software Development Capitalized asset account and credited to Cash or Accounts Payable. For example, if $50,000 is spent, the journal entry would be a debit to Software Development Capitalized for $50,000 and a credit to Cash or Accounts Payable for $50,000.
Leave a Reply